Beyond the Backyard: How Vermont Legalized Attached ADUs in Historic Homes 

Vermont’s ADU Law: A Simple but Powerful Shift 

The 2020 update to Vermont’s state land use statute (Act 179) mandated that municipalities allow one accessory dwelling unit as a permitted use within or attached to a single-family home. Crucially, this means that local zoning boards can no longer block ADUs by requiring discretionary permits or special approvals—as long as the ADU meets certain basic criteria (such as size, code compliance, and location within or attached to the primary structure). 

This removed one of the major barriers homeowners previously faced: the uncertainty of navigating local boards and zoning appeals. In small towns where planning commissions meet infrequently and neighbors have outsized influence, such hurdles often prevented well-intentioned homeowners from even applying. 

Instead, Vermont now treats ADUs much like it does home offices or renovations: a standard building permit suffices. For older homes in particular—many of which already have extra rooms, attics, or walkout basements—this change opened a new world of possibility. 

ADUs in Rural and Historic Contexts 

Unlike dense cities where ADUs often take the form of new backyard cottages, Vermont’s geography and housing stock call for a different model. In towns like Montpelier, Brattleboro, or Barre, many homes were built in the 19th and early 20th centuries, with large floorplans and underused upper levels. Farmhouses, four-squares, and Victorians dot the countryside, often occupied by a single person or couple. 

“These houses were built for families of six or eight, and now it’s just one or two people living there,” says Sarah Edwards, a housing coordinator in Brattleboro. “An attached ADU is a perfect solution. It brings life back into the home without changing the footprint.” 

ADUs in Vermont are more likely to be internal conversions—a finished attic with a kitchenette, a basement walkout unit, or a converted wing of a farmhouse. This means less need for new construction, and lower costs.

Moreover, historic preservation is a major concern in Vermont. Detached backyard units may be harder to permit in designated historic districts, whereas interior modifications allow homeowners to maintain the exterior appearance while still increasing housing supply. 

Supporting Aging in Place and Multi-Generational Living 

One of the primary motivations behind Vermont’s ADU reform was to support aging in place. The state has one of the oldest median ages in the country, and many older residents live in homes that are too large, too costly to maintain, or difficult to navigate. 

An ADU can allow a homeowner to downsize into part of their home while renting out the other portion, providing both income and companionship. Alternatively, it enables adult children or caregivers to move in, offering a balance of independence and support. 

“We built an ADU above our garage for my mom after she retired,” says Michael Shea, a Montpelier resident. “She wanted her own space, but it’s great knowing she’s right next door. And we couldn’t have done it if the town still required a zoning hearing.” 

In some cases, it’s adult children moving into the ADU to save for a down payment while helping with maintenance. These arrangements, while informal, reflect the deeply practical value of flexible housing. 

Economic and Community Benefits 

The economic impact of Vermont’s ADU liberalization is still unfolding, but early indicators are promising. In Brattleboro, for example, local officials report an uptick in building permits related to interior ADU conversions. Most are modest in size—400 to 800 square feet—but offer meaningful contributions to the housing supply. 

ADUs also help small towns retain workforce and vitality. Teachers, tradespeople, healthcare workers, and others often struggle to find housing near their jobs in Vermont’s expensive and supply-constrained market. ADUs can offer relatively affordable rents, especially when owned by local families who prioritize good tenants over maximum profit. 

“When people can live where they work, they’re more likely to volunteer, shop locally, and stay engaged,” says Edwards. “It’s not just about housing units. It’s about community resilience.” 

Challenges Remain: Financing and Awareness 

Despite its strong potential, ADU development in Vermont still faces hurdles. Financing is a key challenge—especially for low- and middle-income homeowners who may have equity but limited cash.

Banks are often wary of lending for small-scale interior renovations without clear rental income history. Homeowners may be hesitant to take on debt without certainty about tenants or long-term returns. State-level grant programs or low-interest loans could help bridge this gap. 

Awareness is another barrier. Many eligible homeowners are simply unaware of the legal change, or unsure how to start the process. To address this, groups like the Vermont Housing Finance Agency (VHFA) have launched toolkits and webinars explaining how to build ADUs and navigate the permitting process. 

In 2022, VHFA even launched a pilot ADU incentive program offering up to $50,000 in grants to qualified homeowners. The program filled up quickly, signaling strong latent demand. 

Lessons for Other Rural States 

Vermont’s experience offers lessons for other rural or semi-rural states looking to address housing needs without large-scale development. Key takeaways include: 

1. Simplify local zoning. Requiring ADUs to go through discretionary review often kills momentum. Clear state-level rules help provide consistency and reduce local resistance. 2. Focus on what already exists. Historic homes and aging housing stock are underused assets. Interior conversions are low-impact but high-benefit. 

3. Tie housing to health and aging policy. ADUs should be part of a broader conversation about aging populations, caregiving, and community-based support. 4. Offer technical and financial assistance. Many homeowners want to do the right thing but need help navigating construction, codes, or financing. 

5. Tell success stories. Showcasing real families who’ve benefited from ADUs helps normalize the idea and inspire others. 

A Quiet Revolution in the Green Mountains 

While it may lack the flash of a multi-billion-dollar housing bond or a sweeping rezoning package, Vermont’s ADU policy represents a quiet revolution. By trusting homeowners, respecting historic contexts, and focusing on practical solutions, the state has opened thousands of doors—literally and figuratively. 

As other states wrestle with how to add housing in rural areas, Vermont’s model shows that sometimes, the answer isn’t in new subdivisions or massive infrastructure. It might just be down the hall, through a shared doorway, or up a staircase in an old house full of new potential.

‍